Behaving Like a CEO [How-To Guide #007]

A Comprehensive Guide for Leaders and Managers

👋 Welcome to a 🔒 subscriber-only edition 🔒 of our Leader Guide newsletter. Every Saturday, we provide a practical deep dive into a complex leadership and management issue. (We share our best free content on LinkedIn).

---

The CEO Mindset: Why It Matters Now More Than Ever

Chief Executive Officers occupy a unique position that requires them to balance strategic vision, operational excellence and day-to-day leadership challenges. In an era of constant disruption—where technological advancements, shifting market trends and global uncertainties collide—today’s leaders must not only respond swiftly but also act decisively to stay ahead. Yet, the trajectory towards a CEO role is often shrouded in mystery, leaving many aspiring professionals feeling uncertain about what precise qualities and behaviours it truly takes to reach the top.

In their seminal work, CEO Next Door, Elena Botelho and Kim Powell demystify this journey. Drawing on thousands of leadership assessments, they dispel the myth that all CEOs are charismatic extroverts from elite backgrounds. Instead, they present a more inclusive view: CEOs come from a range of personal stories and career paths, but the most successful ones share common attributes that anyone can cultivate. These include making decisive moves, building trust, focusing on impact and maintaining unwavering reliability.

This how-to guide adapts the core insights from CEO Next Door into a practical framework designed for aspiring and current leaders alike. Whether you are an experienced executive or an ambitious manager, the lessons within these pages will help you clarify your strengths, close gaps in your leadership style and steer your organisation with greater confidence. You will discover how to nurture vital relationships, handle daunting business decisions and balance short-term demands with long-term vision—all whilst remaining authentic to your own leadership identity.

Over the following sections, we will explore the conceptual underpinnings behind Botelho and Powell’s research, present compelling evidence for why these behaviours directly correlate with business performance and offer a step-by-step process for incorporating them into your professional life. We will also address common barriers—both internal and external—and suggest technologies and metrics you can use to measure progress. By the end, you will be equipped with a practical toolkit that helps you ‘behave like a CEO,’ guiding your organisation, big or small, to sustained success.

---

The CEO Next Door Formula: Breaking Down the Core Traits

Elena Botelho and Kim Powell’s research, based on over 17,000 leadership assessments, sought to understand the core behaviours that define top-performing CEOs. The results challenged longstanding assumptions, showing that the best leaders are not necessarily those with gilded résumés or flawless public personas. Rather, they exhibit four critical behaviours that can be learned, practised and refined over time:

1. Decisiveness
   Great CEOs make decisions quickly and with conviction. This does not imply recklessness; rather, it highlights the importance of gathering sufficient information, trusting your judgement and avoiding analysis paralysis. Decisive leaders move forward even in the face of incomplete data, recognising that inaction often carries greater risks than taking a calculated leap.

2. Reliability
   Consistent delivery builds trust—internally among team members and externally with stakeholders. Botelho and Powell discovered that CEOs who demonstrate reliability in small, everyday matters tend to excel when major crises arise. Reliability extends beyond meeting deadlines. It includes keeping promises, providing transparent communication and being a steady presence even amidst volatility.

3. Engaging for Impact
   CEOs must influence a diverse array of audiences—boards, employees, customers and regulators—often all at once. Effective engagement means forging authentic connections, listening attentively and tailoring communication styles to each stakeholder’s priorities. These interactions are rooted in empathy and guided by a focus on mutual benefit.

4. Adapting Proactively
   In a world that rewards agility, great CEOs anticipate change rather than merely reacting to it. They remain vigilant for emerging trends and encourage continuous learning within their organisations. Adaptation is not about abandoning core principles; it is about evolving them in a way that keeps the business relevant and competitive.

Underlying these behaviours is a mindset shift: recognising that ‘behaving like a CEO’ is neither about inflated egos nor about holding a lofty title. Instead, it is a disciplined commitment to consistent, effective actions that drive tangible outcomes. These actions can be practised whether you are leading a small team, a business unit or an entire corporation.

By internalising these four pillars—decisiveness, reliability, impact-focused engagement and adaptability—you develop the strategic reflexes necessary for upper-tier leadership. The sections that follow will unpack how these traits translate into improved business results, the common roadblocks that can stall your progress and the practical steps you can take to elevate your leadership impact.

---

Why CEO-Level Leadership Translates into Tangible Results

In an economy shaped by fierce competition and rapid change, demonstrating CEO-calibre behaviour is not just about personal ambition. Rather, it directly affects the organisation’s ability to grow, innovate and attract top-tier talent. By integrating the four core behaviours—decisiveness, reliability, engagement for impact and adaptability—leaders at any level can create meaningful gains for their teams and stakeholders.

1. Accelerated Growth and Strategic Outcomes
Companies led by decisive, impactful executives often spot market opportunities sooner, act on them faster and recover more quickly from setbacks. Decision-making agility streamlines business processes, reducing costly delays. Meanwhile, a proactive approach to adaptation guards against organisational complacency, ensuring that the business remains relevant in volatile markets.

2. Enhanced Organisational Culture
By consistently delivering on commitments (reliability) and fostering genuine connections (engagement), leaders model the type of culture that retains employees and drives high performance. High levels of employee satisfaction correlate with increased productivity, lower absenteeism and greater innovation. In fact, a reliable and engaged leadership team is often one of the most cited reasons employees feel valued and stay loyal to an organisation.

3. Increased Stakeholder Confidence
Board members, investors, suppliers and clients crave consistency. Leaders who behave with transparency and reliability build long-term trust that can be leveraged in strategic partnerships or when seeking investment. As a result, the ability to influence multiple stakeholder groups effectively can translate into a stronger negotiating position and more favourable contracts.

4. Risk Mitigation and Preparedness
Adaptability is a crucial hedge against market downturns, new regulatory requirements or technological disruptions. Leaders who are prepared to pivot swiftly and communicate these pivots convincingly are less likely to suffer catastrophic losses. Their emphasis on decisive action and proactive learning creates an environment where potential pitfalls are identified earlier and managed more effectively.

In short, ‘acting like a CEO’ is not a vague aspiration—it’s a set of measurable behaviours that can elevate an organisation’s bottom line, employee engagement and resilience. When these behaviours become ingrained across leadership levels, the cumulative impact drives sustainable success that benefits everyone involved, from front-line staff to executive boards.

---

Roadblocks to CEO-Level Leadership: Confronting Common Pitfalls

Embracing decisive, reliable, impactful and adaptive behaviours may sound straightforward in theory. However, real-world pressures often create obstacles that can stall even the most well-intentioned leadership transformations. Here are some of the most frequent barriers and how they manifest:

1. Fear of Failure
   Many rising leaders hesitate to make bold or swift decisions, worried about the potential fallout from being wrong. This fear can lead to analysis paralysis, where data gathering becomes a substitute for action. Over time, indecision creates frustration and bottlenecks, damaging the trust employees place in leadership.

2. Organisational Inertia
   Long-standing processes and cultural norms can stifle adaptability. For instance, in hierarchical workplaces, decisions may require multiple layers of approval, discouraging quick action. Similarly, organisations that reward rigid conformity over creative thinking may penalise the entrepreneurial instincts that define successful CEOs.

3. Lack of Clarity on Roles and Expectations
   Unclear or conflicting priorities can derail even the most skilled leaders. Without alignment on strategic goals, it becomes difficult to deliver results reliably or engage stakeholders effectively. Mixed messages and an overload of competing objectives can fragment a leader’s focus.

4. Complex Stakeholder Landscapes
   A modern CEO navigates a web of interests—from shareholders to customers, regulatory bodies to employees. Attempting to please everyone can dilute decision-making and compromise reliability. Leaders must learn to prioritise and communicate trade-offs clearly, a skill that eludes many.

5. Personal Blind Spots
   Whether it is overconfidence or too much humility, personal biases can hamper self-awareness and hinder growth. For instance, a leader who overvalues consensus might avoid conflict, thereby stalling decisive action. Conversely, a leader who underestimates the significance of empathy may struggle to engage teams for meaningful impact.

6. Burnout and Mental Fatigue
   Constantly adapting to external pressures, delivering under tight deadlines and juggling multiple responsibilities can drain leaders. When exhaustion sets in, reliability and engagement inevitably suffer. This can create a domino effect, weakening team cohesion and eroding trust.

Understanding these pitfalls is the first step towards overcoming them. In the next section, we will delve into a structured framework that helps leaders put the core CEO Next Door behaviours into practice—offering concrete strategies to break through these barriers and position yourself for lasting success.

---

From Aspiration to Action: A Step-by-Step Guide to CEO-Level Behaviour

Translating the insights from CEO Next Door into everyday practice requires a systematic approach. Below is a structured framework designed to embed decisiveness, reliability, impact-focused engagement and adaptability into your leadership routine.